Watson to Holmes

Watson to Holmes

Locked case

HOLMES · 60 minutes · 6 suspects

Little chalk men keep appearing on Hugh Thorne's sundial, and his American wife goes white at every one. He wants them read.

6 cases a month · about $1.33 a case

Unlock with Silver · 6 cases a monthRenews at $7.99$4.99first month

Renews at $7.99/month · cancel anytime · refundable only if unopened

11 cases a month · about $1.18 a case

Unlock with Gold · 11 cases a monthRenews at $12.99$9.99first month

Renews at $12.99/month · cancel anytime · refundable only if unopened

All 24 cases · under $1 a case · about 20 hours of mysteries

Platinum · every caseRenews at $17.99$14.99first month

Renews at $17.99/month · cancel anytime · refundable only if unopened

This case is not free right now. Silver opens it. Free players get 1 case free at a time, a new one every 2 weeks (the next switch is Sat 5 Dec).

How Crimefloor works

Free players
1 case free at a time, a new one every 2 weeks. One case from the archive is free for two weeks at a time: an easy one, then a medium one, in turn (the pick changes every other Saturday at 9:00 AM IST). Finish a free case while it is free and your verdict stays yours. An unfinished one locks when it stops being free, and picks up where you left it if you get access again.
Silver · Gold · Platinum
Silver and Gold: open any cases you pick, a set number of each difficulty every billing month. Platinum: every case in the archive. Every case you solve stays yours forever, even if you cancel.
  • Free right now: A Private View
  • Next free case changes: Sat 5 Dec
The Chalk Men: the scene

The suspects

  • Portrait of Vince Kale, a suspect in The Chalk MenVince Kale
  • Portrait of Lacey Thorne, a suspect in The Chalk MenLacey Thorne
  • Portrait of Martin Rudd, a suspect in The Chalk MenMartin Rudd
  • Portrait of Clare Thorne, a suspect in The Chalk MenClare Thorne
  • Portrait of Dan Hart, a suspect in The Chalk MenDan Hart
  • Portrait of Joan Pell, a suspect in The Chalk MenJoan Pell

Case file 24INTRIGUEHOLMES · Hard · 60 min: Everyone is hiding something. Only the best get this one.

The Chalk Men

Little chalk men keep appearing on Hugh Thorne's sundial, and his American wife goes white at every one. He wants them read.

The scene

Ridling Hall, a flint-and-brick house on Hickling Broad in Norfolk, and Elder Farm up the footpath. Thursday night, 15 October 2026: low cloud, wet lawns, rain due at dawn.

Client: Hugh Thorne. Who is writing the chalk men at Ridling Hall?

An original mystery inspired by a classic detective story for the Holmes tier. Read the statements and evidence on the floor, rule out suspects, then name the culprit, the motive and the two cards that prove it.

The suspects

  • Vince KaleAn American at Elder Farm
  • Lacey ThorneHugh's wife
  • Martin RuddNeighbour across the Broad
  • Clare ThorneHugh's sister
  • Dan HartBoatman and reed cutter
  • Joan PellHousekeeper